Convergence Fall 2016: Midterm: Project Proposal

Thursday, November 3, 2016

Midterm: Project Proposal

A: For my final project, I am looking to write a research paper which will delve into the sports media landscape, more specifically, how the platforms for viewing and consuming sports has shifted. A statistic that got me interested in this topic was that television viewer ratings for the NFL has been dropping at unforeseen rates this season. NFL football had long been seen as being exempt from dropping television viewer patterns, and although other factors have been blamed for this, the fact remains that less and less people are watching sports on live television.

Various other platforms for viewing and consuming sports have usurped the need to watch any game on TV anymore. From companies like FOX and ESPN releasing apps which allow a user to watch programming on that channel from their smartphone.

B. An alternative pitch for my final project, I would like to investigate the ongoing corruption scandals happening with the soccer world governing body of FIFA. I would like to create an interactive timeline which details the events and decisions surrounding the very controversial activities of FIFA.

Eight individuals have already pled guilty to varying charges concerning the corruption scandal, and even a corporation (Traffic Sports USA) has pled guilty. Fourteen additional individuals have been formally accused. I feel that this is a more narrowed down project. Interestingly, the United States Department of Justice has been the forerunner in investigating and punishing the individuals involved.

I have done plenty of preliminary research and plan on watching the BBC Panorama program which did a special on this topic called Foul!: The Secret World of FIFA: Bribes, Vote Rigging and Ticket Scandals. This was the groundbreaking documentary that uncovered this scandal to the public. Plenty of journalists have done work on this topic already and I hope to create an interactive timeline which simplifies the entire situation for someone who isn't privy to the fine details of the story. I would like to also cover the bids for the 2018 and 2022 FIFA World Cups which are also shrouded in controversy.

3 comments:

UnknownNovember 10, 2016 at 7:18 AM
Yeah Cameron, like I said before, I definitely think you should go with the FIFA story.

It would do a big deal of digging, but it would look awesome on a resume. Once you figure out how to design that interactive timeline, I think it would be a great site for curious people like me (who know nothing about FIFA) to learn about what goes on behind the scenes.

Maybe ask Professor Bergeland for help on designing this interactive timeline.
ReplyDelete
Replies
UnknownNovember 13, 2016 at 1:40 PM
Hey Cameron,

I already expressed my interest in the FIFA story during class, so I am here again to encourage you to pursue this topic!! During my time as a journalist, I have come across too many people that don't trust us. We have a bad rep., unfortunately, and if you did this right, and continue to uncover more details in the future, you could be the start of something new for people who have lost faith in good, honest reporting. A LOT of people do not know what's going on, and if you can recap what went on and continue to investigate the problem...ethically, you would seriously be doing a good deal for not only journalists but for people that deserve to know the truth.

I hope you choose topic B, and I agree with Frank! go to Bergeland!
ReplyDelete
Replies
Anthony SantiagoNovember 15, 2016 at 3:03 PM
Cam,

I think you should definelty choose the topic of the FIFA scandal. Not only is it arguably the largest most powerful organization in sports, it is also notoriously the most corrupt. Even though everyone in the soccer community knows of all the corruption that occurs, everyone seems to push it under the rug and act as if nothing is wrong. I think this project could shed light on the current issues for both soccer fanatics and people who know nothing about the sport.
ReplyDelete
Replies

Add comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Last Class 12/22 11:45pm - 2:45pm

Remainder of Final Project Presentations - Attendance mandatory

Please bring snacks to share *if you can.

___________________

Due 12/8 and 12/22 Project Presentations

12/15 No Class - Reading Day

FINAL PROJECTS!! (due on the blog on 12/7 before 8pm)

Checklist:

-project summary on the blog along with images

-a link to your project including written projects which must be published somewhere or linked as pdfs. Some projects can be included in the post itself ex: videos embedded.

-presentations will be from your blog post or linked directly from the post PLEASE TEST THIS BEFORE ARRIVING IN CLASS - 5 minutes MAX.

-written projects (research papers, essays, zines or other projects that will be distributed in print) must be handed in to me in print.

-all students must included in your blog post a final resources list/bibliography

-I have invited guests to attend our final presentations.

Extra Credit Post +5% (due on blog by 12/15) Selfie: Us and Them exhibition at Living Incubator Performance Space - Gateway Projects at 2 Gateway Center

Please look closely at the pieces in the art exhibition Selfie: Us and Them. Form a ~500 word response to the experience of seeing this exhibition. Please be sure to address the following questions:

What are some themes of the exhibition? How do the artists address identity and the selfie? What are some critiques of self, identity and media? Describe at least two of the projects in detail and explain how the projects are or can be activist in their messages? How does the exhibition use and address media in order to critique identity and self portraiture? What are the artists and curators telling the gallery audience?

NOTE **All outstanding posts due 12/15 for partial credit** If you missed an assignment and would like to complete it for partial credit(as much as half) this is your chance. You must email the link to your assignment to the professor and let her know that you would like the LATE assignment considered toward your final grade.

TWEET! twitter counts as extra participation credit!

____________________

HAPPY THANKSGIVING! No Class 11/24

Due 12/1

READINGS: Jenkins, Conclusion pg. 251- 270. Afterword pg. 271-294 and pdf on Blackboard called Sleeper Curve (was not appearing last week but is available now)

WORK ON YOUR SEMESTER PROJECTS!!! check your proposal posts for comments from your fellow students and from me. I will be adding more comments all week.

Group 7 presents

2 Tweets #convergcult

COMMENTS ON 3 PROJECT PROPOSALS (if you have not done so already) please comment with helpful criticism, resources, adjacent projects or ideas on 3 fellow student project proposals. Be helpful!

______________________

Due 11/17

We are meeting in the classroom and then walking to 2 Gateway Center together. We will be visiting Gateway Projects Space and specifically an exhibition in the Living Incubator Performance Space called Selfie. Please be here on time.

READINGS: pdf on Blackboard called Sleeper Curve

Post 4 - Transmedia storytelling Analysis

What is the difference between multimedia and transmedia?Choose a message/story/product that uses multiple platforms to expand the reach and experience of a story (idea.) Choose an example that has not been discussed in class. Use the readings from class and additional readings to analyze how this story is told using various platforms (including ARG, games, social media, traditional media, etc.) How does this strategy engage participation? How does the use of various platforms benefit or change the story or the audience?

Challenge Media and the Presidential Election: If you choose to please try to use the presidential election (2016 or previous) as an example to illustrate the strategy of splitting the narrative onto multiple platforms. Does this happen? Can this happen? How? Please use examples and research to back up your claim.

Find research to back up your argument. Use various essays/articles to speak to your points. Cite your research. 7+ paragraphs, with images and citations.

No group presentation

COMMENTS ON 3 PROJECT PROPOSALS please comment with helpful criticism, resources, adjacent projects or ideas on 3 fellow student project proposals. Be helpful!

____________________

Due 11/10

READINGS: Pavlik/McIntosh, Chapter 5 and Jenkins, Searching for the Origami Unicorn pg.95-134

Group 6 presents

2 Tweets #convergcult

COMMENTS ON 3 PROJECT PROPOSALS please comment with helpful criticism, resources, adjacent projects or ideas on 3 fellow student project proposals. Be helpful!

______________

Due 11/3

READINGS: Pavlik/McIntosh, Chapter 7

2 Tweets #convergcult

Group 5 presents

_________________

Due 10/27

MIDTERM PRESENTATIONS in class on 10/27**Please arrive in class 5 minutes before class begins at 2:25pm

Proposal of final semester project. In a two page (700+ word description printed and handed in to me) please explain: the topic, the form your project will take, the scope of your research, intended message of your piece, the audience you would like to reach (be specific - of course you may want it to reach the broadest audience possible - but who are you directing it towards specifically), the way(s) you intend to distribute or publish your work, how it will involve your audience, how do you intend it to "make change", why are you making this project, why is it important to you, how does this project fit in to your portfolio or career ambitions, how will you produce this project, how are you taking advantage of convergence in the project or in the distribution of the project, how do you plan to make something amazing.

Please include a Bibliography and/or Resource List for semester project (so far) in addition to your 2+ page description. Please use proper MLA or Chicago style. Include any academic research/scholarship, literature, inspirational projects, media works you are looking to, any resources you plan to use in order to create the project, expertise you plan to employ, help you will be seeking to accomplish your ambitious goals, all materials and information you hope to access to complete the project.

HAND IN TO ME YOUR PRINTED 2+ PAGE midterm proposal and bibliography/resource list as you enter the classroom on 10/27

Then you will give a 2 minute presentation to the class.On the blog create a NEW extensive summary post, a "pitch" to the class of your project proposal. This must be posted on or before 10/26 at 11:59pm. Presentations will be from your blog post and should explain where you are in your research and production of your project and how and where you plan to be at the final presentation. What are you making, why and how? Please concise, clear and impressive! Practice your presentations for clarity and for time. Use visuals (images in your post) if appropriate. Be sure the class and I will fully understand exactly what you plan to make and why.

You will be graded on the proposal you hand in, on your blog post and on your presentation "pitch" to the class.

________________

Due 10/20

READINGS: Pavlik/McIntosh, Chapter 9 and Chapter 10

Group 4 presents

2 Tweets with #convergcult

________________

Due 10/13

READINGS: Pavlik/McIntosh, Chapter 8 Jenkins, Spoiling Survivor pg. 25-58 and

ONLINE: David Carr's Last Word on Journalism, Aimed at Students, New York Times, February 2015http://www.nytimes.com/2015/02/16/business/media/david-carr-as-a-passionate-professor-shaping-the-future-of-journalism.html

Clay Shirky, Newspapers and Thinking the Unthinkable, March 2009 http://www.shirky.com/weblog/2009/03/newspapers-and-thinking-the-unthinkable/

Two short articles from Brain Pickings by Maria Popova:

The Life of Trailblazing Journalist Nellie Bly, Who Paved the Way for Women in Media https://www.brainpickings.org/2015/07/17/the-daring-nellie-bly-bonnie-christensen/

Addiction to Truth: David Carr, the Measure of a Person, and the Uncommon Art of Elevating the Common Recordhttps://www.brainpickings.org/2015/02/13/david-carr-night-of-the-gun/

POST 3 Mass Amateurization

In the readings Everyone is a Media Outlet and Publish, Then Filter, Clay Shirky describes "mass amateurization." Explain what he means by this and give a clear example from your experience that illustrates his argument. What does Shirky argue is the outcome of this? How has media publishing and consumption changed as a result of this? Similarly Jenkins in Why Heather Can Write describes fan fiction culture and the amateurization of the author. Please use examples to explain this development.

What do you feel is the future of the media professional? What do these two readings suggest may be shifting, if anything, and what may come of these new authors/storytellers, journalists and producers?

Feel free to use other essays/articles as well to speak to this points. ~800 words, with several images (with captions), citations from the readings and works cited.

Important note on Post 3:

The post should be a strong analysis of the readings. Be sure to convey an understanding of the readings and cite them extensively. Use media examples to illustrate your points from these readings and those of your own choosing. These should be titled (create a strong title), carefully written, well edited and properly cited with bibliographic information at the bottom of each post. All posts should include illustrative images with captions and links that are clear and introduced in your text.

*Please be sure that your published post is formatted correctly with spacing, alignment, paragraphs, images and captions of images lined up as best as possible. Fonts and images should be sized correctly. Please remember these are on the web. Format them to reflect your best published writing for the web with images and text appearing as polished as possible. This is a good part of the writing grade. EDIT!

2 Tweets #convergcult

Group 3 presents

Group presentations must also have a summary posted to the blog. One post per group. Best to complete this before your presentation in class. For those who have presented please do this immediately. This post is part of your presentation grade.

2 Comments on project proposals. Read through student project proposals. Choose two or more to give feedback and help with/give additional resources, advice or references. Be constructive and thoughtful.

____________

Due 10/6

READINGS: Pavlik/McIntosh, Chapter 6, ON BLACKBOARD: Clay Shirky, Everyone is a Media Outlet and Publish, Then Filter

++Draft Proposal Due for Semester Project++

Please choose and describe the topic which you plan to research for your semester project. See the project description at the end of your syllabus for the guidelines of the project. Write up a description of the social issue, of the research you plan on undertaking and what you plan on creating to approach this topic (video, podcast, vlog, tumblr campaign, workshop, research paper, article, poster, art project etc). Please include as much information as possible at this stage. 1 page+ printed and handed in to me AND a post on the blog. You may include images and links to supporting material. This proposal will count towards your midterm grade. You will be presenting your topic in short presentations as your midterm on 10/27. Please dive into this proposal as it is crucial to your success on the midterm and final.

Group 2 presents

2 Tweets with #convergcult

_______________

Due 9/29

READINGS: Pavlik/McIntosh, Chapter 3 and Clay Shirky, Everyone is a Media Outlet on Blackboard and Jenkins, Why Heather Can Write pg.175-216

Group 1 presents

2 Tweets with #convergcult

EDIT POST 2

Important note on Posts: The posts should be strong analyses of the readings. Be sure to convey an understanding of the readings and cite them extensively. Use media examples to illustrate your argument and points from the readings. These should be titled (create a strong title), carefully written, well edited and properly cited. All posts should include illustrative images (with captions) and useful links that are clear and introduced in your text. Be sure to include a bibliography/works cited at the end of your post. You may use MLA or any accepted style in order to cite, but please be sure to be consistent and check your format.

GROUP PRESENTATIONS must also have a summary posted to the blog. One post per group. Best to complete this before your presentation in class. Please summarize your presentation and include images and links to the most important examples and information. For those who have already presented please do this immediately. This post is part of your presentation grade.You might consider having your presentation online and linked from the post to make it easier to present in class. You may bring your presentation with you but be sure to have a back up way of accessing the presentation as there is always room for a technical problem.

_______________

Due 9/22

POST 2 DUE Society of the Spectacle

What is the society of the spectacle? How does Debord describe the spectacle and its impact? Discuss the theme of commodity as described by Debord in this chapter specifically. What is the commodity as spectacle? Please use your readings about the media, convergence and spectacle to help illustrate your descriptions and your points. Use clear examples from contemporary mediated culture to help explain your interpretations of this text.

You must cite from your sources (in body citation) and use images (at least 2) to illustrate your examples. Feel free to also link to additional resources and information.

500+ words posted on this blog: well-developed, edited, and formatted correctly. Please make sure to include a short works cited list at the bottom of the blog.

READINGS:

Jenkins, Introduction to Convergence Culture pgs.1-24

Pavlik/McIntosh, Chapter 1+2

From Guy Debord's Society of the Spectacle (first published 1967):

Debord, The Commodity as Spectacle (1977 translation)OR(2002 translation)

2 Tweets with #convergcult

_______________

DUE Thursday 9/15

Introduce yourself on the blog - MINI POST

Please post 1 paragraph about yourself and your professional and academic goals. How do media, media consumption and media studies fit into your life, your academic goals and your interests? You must include one image and one link.

READINGS:

Jenkins, Introduction to Convergence Culture pgs.1-24

Pavlik/McIntosh, Chapter 1+2

From Guy Debord's Society of the Spectacle (first published 1967):

Debord, The Commodity as Spectacle (1977 translation)OR(2002 translation)

2 Tweets with #convergcult

_________________________

Link to Syllabus

Link to online videos (links) from class screenings

Readings on the syllabus refer to chapters in your texts:

John V. Pavlik and Shawn McIntosh's Converging Media and

Henry Jenkins' Convergence Culture: Where Old and New Media Collide

**Additional readings can be found on the Blackboard site or linked here and will be specified here for each class. Please check here each week for additional readings.

CLASS DISCUSSIONS:

The course material and discussions can often be provocative and challenging. We must therefore be careful to be respectful of each other and all of our viewpoints. No student shall ever be made to feel uncomfortable because of race, gender, sexual orientation or religious beliefs.

We must come to class prepared and ready to discuss the readings!! Please keep discussions focused on the readings and class materials and keep examples relevant and appropriate. If you have not done the readings you are not to participate in the discussion.

Please see this great list of classroom discussion guidelines for guidance on classroom discussion. It is also helpful that everyone in the course reviews several key terms that are often important to the class discussion. Please review this important list of terms.